The best retro toaster for most kitchens is the Keenstone 2-Slice (WT-330): it has 1.5-inch slots, an 18/8 stainless steel body and the biggest rating pool of any model here, 4.4/5 from 25,737 Amazon ratings. If you toast thick bagels or sourdough most mornings, the Aigostar has the widest slots on this list at 1.6 inches. If you want the 1950s look with a brand name attached, the Smeg TSF01 is the one people mean, at several times the price.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Color is the easy part of choosing a retro toaster. We sorted these by the two numbers that decide whether one works for you: how wide the slot is (will your bread fit) and how much counter it takes. Then we read what owners complain about, because a toaster that looks right and burns one side of the toast still burns one side of the toast.
How we chose
We did not test these toasters in a kitchen. We compared manufacturer spec sheets (Smeg USA, Nostalgia) with the Amazon listings for slot width, wattage, browning levels and dimensions, and read Amazon’s review summaries and star distributions for each model. All ratings below were checked on November 13, 2026. Where a maker doesn’t publish a number, the table says so instead of guessing.
Retro toasters compared
| Model | Slot width | Power | Browning levels | Footprint (L x W x H, in) | Amazon rating (Nov 2026) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Keenstone WT-330 | 1.5 in | 825 W | 6 | 11.6 x 7.1 x 7.5 | 4.4/5, 25,737 ratings |
| Nostalgia NRTOS2RR | Not published (“extra-wide”) | 900 W | 5 | 14 x 8 x 9 | 4.6/5, 10,144 ratings |
| Aigostar B30202H3L | 1.6 in | 800 W | 6 | 11.23 x 7.28 x 7.28 | 4.3/5, 1,332 ratings |
| Smeg TSF01 | 1.4 in | 980 W | 6 | 12.2 x 7.7 x 7.75 | 4.4/5, 3,906 ratings |
| Mueller Home MR 220 | Not published | 800 W | 7 | 11.5 x 6.5 x 6.9 | 4.0/5, 1,310 ratings |
Two patterns stand out. First, the cheap models aren’t lower powered than you’d expect: all five sit between 800 and 980 watts, so wattage alone won’t separate them. Second, footprint varies more than the photos suggest. By the listed dimensions, the Nostalgia covers about 112 square inches of counter and the Mueller about 75, a difference of roughly a third.
1. Keenstone 2-Slice Toaster (WT-330): best overall
The Keenstone is a rounded stainless body with a flat lever, a browning dial and three buttons: bagel, defrost and cancel. Keenstone lists 18/8 stainless steel, 1.5-inch slots, 825 watts and a removable crumb tray, and the color range runs from white and beige to pink, green, blue and black.
Who it’s for: anyone who wants the diner look on a normal budget and toasts a mix of sandwich bread, English muffins and the occasional bagel.
Who should skip it: people who want a dedicated reheat button and nothing else will do; see the cons.
Pros
- Largest rating pool here: 4.4/5 from 25,737 Amazon ratings.
- 1.5-inch slots, wide enough for the thick breads Keenstone names (bagels, Texas toast).
- Amazon’s review summary says owners find it works well and looks good, and that the bagel setting does its job.
- Compact at 11.6 x 7.1 inches and about 3.1 pounds.
Cons
- The listing contradicts itself: the title mentions reheat, while the feature list names only bagel, defrost and cancel. Check the button panel in the photos if reheat matters to you.
- Amazon flags a newer touchscreen version, so the classic model may be phased out in some colors.
- 825 watts is mid-pack; the Smeg and Nostalgia draw more.
2. Nostalgia Retro Wide 2-Slice Toaster: best rated, boldest colors
Nostalgia’s toaster leans furthest into the 1950s look, with lighted bagel, defrost and cancel buttons and colors such as red, pink and aqua. Nostalgia rates it at 900 watts with five browning levels, a slide-out crumb tray and cord storage in the base.
Who it’s for: buyers who care most about color and want the highest average rating on this list.
Who should skip it: small kitchens, and anyone who wants fine browning control.
Pros
- Highest average here: 4.6/5 from 10,144 Amazon ratings.
- Highest power of the budget models at 900 watts.
- Lighted buttons show which mode is active.
Cons
- Biggest footprint: Nostalgia lists 14 x 8 x 9 inches and 5 pounds.
- Only five browning levels and no reheat button.
- Nostalgia calls the slots “extra-wide” but doesn’t publish a width, so you can’t compare it on paper with the others.
3. Aigostar Retro 2-Slice Toaster: widest slots
The Aigostar has 1.6-inch slots, the widest published number in this group, plus four functions (bagel, defrost, reheat, cancel), six browning settings and a high-lift carriage for pulling out small pieces. It’s rated at 800 watts.
Who it’s for: people who toast bagels, thick sourdough or homemade loaves often and want every function button.
Who should skip it: anyone who wants the most proven unit; its rating pool is small and the complaints are real.
Pros
- 1.6-inch slots; Amazon’s summary says owners like how they handle thicker breads and bagels.
- Only toaster here with bagel, defrost, reheat and cancel all listed.
- High-lift lever for English muffin halves.
Cons
- Mixed reports on evenness: some owners say it toasts only one side and the outside gets too hot.
- Durability concerns, including reports of it breaking after two months; 9% of ratings are 1-star.
- 4.3/5 from 1,332 ratings, a much thinner track record than Keenstone or Nostalgia.
4. Smeg TSF01: the splurge
The TSF01 is the toaster most “retro kitchen” photos are built around. Smeg USA lists 980 watts, 1.4-inch slots with self-centering racks, six browning levels, reheat, defrost and bagel functions, a polished stainless steel crumb tray, a 39-inch cord and a 5-pound weight. Smeg also sells a sandwich rack (TSSR01) that fits it.
Who it’s for: people matching a Smeg kettle or coffee maker, or anyone who wants the chrome base and ball-lever details the copies imitate.
Who should skip it: anyone who expects the price to buy better toast. Owner reports don’t support that.
Pros
- Most powerful here at 980 watts, with self-centering racks for slices of different thickness.
- 4.4/5 from 3,906 Amazon ratings, 79% of them 5-star.
- Full spec sheet published by the maker, including cord length.
Cons
- Narrowest published slot in the group at 1.4 inches.
- Amazon’s summary lists reports of uneven toasting, a lever that won’t stay down and units failing within nine months; 10% of ratings are 1-star.
- Costs several times what the Keenstone does.
5. Mueller Home Retro Toaster (MR 220): smallest footprint
The Mueller is the most compact toaster here at 11.5 x 6.5 x 6.9 inches and 2.2 pounds. It has seven browning levels, the most on this list, plus reheat, defrost and cancel, self-centering slots and auto shut-off. Mueller says the design is free of Teflon and PTFE.
Who it’s for: small apartments and dorm-sized counters where the household eats regular square sandwich bread.
Who should skip it: bagel eaters. Owners report the slots are too narrow for bagels.
Pros
- Smallest footprint, about 75 square inches.
- Seven browning levels.
- Owners in Amazon’s summary say it works well with standard square slices.
Cons
- No bagel button, and owners report bagels don’t fit the slots properly; Mueller doesn’t publish a slot width.
- Reports of uneven toasting; 13% of ratings are 1-star, and the average is the lowest here at 4.0/5 from 1,310 ratings.
- Wattage sources disagree: Amazon lists 800 watts, some resellers list 1,500. We used the Amazon figure.
How to choose a retro toaster
Start with your bread, not the color
Slot width decides what fits. If bagels or thick homemade bread are a weekly thing, stay at 1.5 inches or wider (Keenstone, Aigostar). If you mostly toast sliced sandwich bread, the narrower Smeg or the Mueller is fine. When a maker only says “extra-wide” without a number, treat it as unknown and read owner photos.
Measure the spot on your counter
Retro bodies are rounder and wider than plain box toasters. Measure the space between your backsplash and the counter edge and compare it with the footprint column above. Also check the height under your upper cabinets if the toaster will live there; the Nostalgia is the tallest at 9 inches.
Decide which buttons you’ll use
Every model here has defrost and cancel. Bagel mode (one-sided toasting) is missing on the Mueller; reheat is missing on the Nostalgia and unclear on the Keenstone. If you reheat cold toast often, the Aigostar, Smeg and Mueller list it clearly.
Weigh the rating pool, not only the average
A 4.4 from 25,000 ratings tells you more than a 4.3 from 1,300. Also look at the share of 1-star ratings: 9% to 13% for the Aigostar, Smeg and Mueller, and their review summaries tie those to failures and uneven toasting rather than looks. If long life matters most, read our piece on whether retro or modern toasters last longer.
Quick decision rule
- Want one toaster that does everything reasonably well: Keenstone.
- Want the brightest color and best average rating, and have the counter space: Nostalgia.
- Toast bagels and thick slices most days: Aigostar.
- Matching a Smeg kettle or coffee maker: Smeg TSF01.
- Tiny counter, square bread only: Mueller.
Building a whole matching counter? Our retro electric kettle and retro coffee maker comparisons use the same spec-first approach.
FAQ
Do retro toasters toast as well as regular toasters?
The styling doesn’t decide it; the five models here all draw 800 to 980 watts, and evenness complaints show up for both the cheapest and the most expensive one. Owner reviews and the share of 1-star ratings tell you more than the housing does.
What slot width do I need for bagels?
Keenstone (1.5 inches) and Aigostar (1.6 inches) both name bagels in their listings, and Aigostar owners confirm thick breads fit. The Mueller, with no published width, draws complaints that bagels don’t fit.
Is the Smeg toaster worth the money?
It is if the look and matching other Smeg appliances matter to you. On paper it has the most power here (980 W) but the narrowest slot (1.4 in), and its owner complaints about uneven toasting and lever problems are similar to cheaper models’.
Should I buy a vintage toaster instead?
An original mid-century toaster can be a great piece, but it needs checking before daily use. Our guides on spotting a collectible retro toaster and restoring a vintage toaster cover what to look for. A new retro-style model gets you the look with modern functions like defrost and auto pop-up.
Sources
All checked November 13, 2026.
- Smeg USA, TSF01 product page and spec sheet: smeg.com/us/products/TSF01SSUS (slot width, power, cord length, dimensions, weight)
- Nostalgia Products, Retro Wide 2-Slice Toaster NRTOS2RR: nostalgiaproducts.com (wattage, browning levels, dimensions, weight)
- Amazon listing ASIN B08CKBDQJJ, Keenstone WT-330 (slot width, wattage, dimensions, weight, rating, review summary)
- Amazon listing ASIN B09W3Z3MTL, Nostalgia NRTOS2RR (rating and count)
- Amazon listing ASIN B0CBB332WQ, Aigostar B30202H3L (slot width, wattage, functions, dimensions, rating, star distribution, review summary)
- Amazon listing ASIN B094YMGX56, Smeg TSF01 matte black (rating, star distribution, review summary)
- Amazon listing ASIN B0DJ9YN1K9, Mueller Home MR 220 (wattage, browning levels, dimensions, weight, rating, star distribution, review summary)