For families or households that need to toast multiple slices at once, a 4-slice retro toaster combines capacity, speed, and timeless design. These models are perfect for busy mornings when everyone wants their breakfast at the same time, and they also bring a nostalgic style to the kitchen that goes beyond simple functionality. The best 4-slice toasters of 2025 balance large-capacity performance with even browning, durability, and aesthetic appeal.

Smeg TSF03 4-Slice Toaster

The Smeg TSF03 takes the design principles of the TSF01 and expands them for families. Its bold, curved body and polished chrome accents give it a distinctive 1950s charm, and the range of color options makes it easy to match any kitchen décor. The Smeg TSF03 features extra-wide slots that can handle thicker artisan breads, bagels, and specialty loaves, and each side of the toaster operates independently with its own six-level browning control. This allows multiple family members to toast bread to their preferred darkness at the same time.

Performance is a strong point for this model. The high-quality nichrome heating elements ensure consistent and even browning across all four slices. The defrost, reheat, and bagel functions provide additional versatility, making it easy to handle frozen bread or toasted bagel halves without burning. Despite its larger size, the toaster heats quickly, and the stainless steel body retains heat efficiently to maintain consistent results. Users frequently note that even with all four slots in use, every slice comes out evenly browned without uneven edges or cold spots.

Durability and user convenience are equally impressive. The removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning, while the cool-touch exterior ensures safety during use. The independent side controls and high-lift lever make it easy to check or remove slices, even when toasting a mix of thin and thick bread. Families also appreciate the sturdy construction, which feels substantial on the countertop and built to last for years of daily use. Many users comment that it not only performs well but also elevates the kitchen visually, combining form and function in a way that makes morning routines smoother and more enjoyable.

Pros include retro design with multiple color options, independent dual controls for customized browning, extra-wide slots, consistent even toasting across all four slices, and durable stainless steel construction. Cons include its larger footprint, which requires more countertop space, and a higher price compared to smaller 2-slice models.

KitchenAid 4-Slice Artisan Toaster

The KitchenAid 4-Slice Artisan Toaster is built for households that demand both style and performance. Its die-cast metal body and iconic tilt-head lever provide a timeless and elegant look, while the extra-wide slots and seven shade settings allow precise customization for every slice of bread. Like the Smeg, it has independent side controls, so multiple family members can toast different bread types at the same time without compromise.

Performance is consistently reliable. The motorized lift system ensures smooth operation and easy retrieval of smaller items like English muffins, while the heating elements deliver even browning across all four slices. The high-lift lever also makes it easy to remove toast without touching the interior, and the toaster remains stable during use thanks to its heavy base. Users consistently praise its combination of elegant design and precise functionality, noting that even with multiple slices in use, toast comes out perfectly every time.

KitchenAid also focuses on durability. The die-cast metal construction and insulated exterior make it a long-lasting addition to the kitchen, capable of handling daily family use without degrading performance. The removable crumb tray simplifies cleaning, and the overall design is versatile enough to complement both retro and modern kitchen aesthetics. While it is a premium option, families who want a stylish and functional toaster that can handle heavy use will find it to be a worthwhile investment.

Pros include robust construction, extra-wide slots, independent dual controls, precise browning with seven settings, smooth motorized lift, and stylish design. Cons include higher price and slightly larger footprint.

Final Thoughts

Both the Smeg TSF03 and KitchenAid 4-Slice Artisan Toaster offer excellent solutions for families who want efficiency, reliability, and retro-inspired style. The Smeg TSF03 is ideal for those who want bold colors, classic charm, and versatile functionality in a high-capacity toaster. The KitchenAid Artisan is perfect for families seeking premium construction, smooth operation, and precise control over browning. Either choice provides consistent results for four slices at a time and adds a nostalgic touch to your kitchen while meeting the demands of busy mornings.

Before you make your final choice, check out our full Retro Toaster Buyer’s Guide. It breaks down everything you need to know about materials, durability, heating performance, and extra features so you can pick the perfect toaster for your kitchen.